Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Genevieve Van Cleve's avatar

I’m a fifth generation Texan and I had to break up with my beloved home state. On the car ride up to Olympia, I wept. I played every break up song I could find. It felt like giving up. I did 20 years in Texas politics- my patch was getting pro-choice women elected and training staff. I couldn’t do it anymore. It hurt too much. Once my step kids were grown, my Dad and Grandma passed away- there was nothing left to stay for. I selfishly wanted to live the remainder of my life in a place not quite so hot, mean, and stupid. I have survivors guilt, but it doesn’t hold a candle to the violence and indignity that millions of Texans suffer at the hands of white people in charge… same as it ever was. I hope the kids burn it down, and along the way learn to govern. The average dictatorship lasts for about 15 years. Surely, there’s an overdue reckoning around the corner? - but Pete and I couldn’t wait any longer. I pray for peace, but secretly hope for revenge. I’m not proud of that, but then again we’re dealing with folks who kick children in rivers and watch women die on concertina wire. So fuck them. I love the people, the landscape, the diversity, and the ridiculousness of my home state. I love the art and music. I love HEB… the only functioning statewide energency response we have. Texas has always been tough, but life is short. Get out while you can. Bring your old people and kids with you. America is so much better than the Lonestar State.

Expand full comment
cognomun's avatar

The descriptor "evil" being applied roused my interest. I tended to attach (a now discredited) genetic predisposition to the word, i.e., "the evil XYY." So I examined the etymology and found (condensed version): In Old English and other older Germanic languages other than Scandinavian, "this word is the most comprehensive adjectival expression of disapproval, dislike or disparagement" [OED]. Evil was the word the Anglo-Saxons used where we would use bad, cruel, unskillful, defective (adj.). In Middle English, bad took the wider range of senses and evil began to focus on moral badness. Both words have good as their opposite.

Also as a noun in Old English, "what is bad; sin, wickedness; anything that causes injury, morally or physically." Especially of a malady or disease from c. 1200. The meaning "extreme moral wickedness, conduct contrary to standards of morals or righteousness," was one of the senses of the Old English noun, but it did not become established as the main sense of the modern word until 18c. (And if I may add, perfected by the governor and his cronies.)

••••Thus informed, I find it most appropriate if not exigent in usage as applied herein.

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts